How would you deal with a non-believer in your holy place?

like you, I do miss the 'hanging out' together thing that we used to have at the old church..........but back then, we had things that we did together, like taking care of the old folks' yards and painting their porches and stuff (we were youngsters then).... I miss singing in the choir, too....if you're open to it, there's a Universal Unitarian type church somewhere near you.... they wouldn't mind having you at all!!!.... and your idea of an 'all faiths club' would still leave out us agnostics and atheists.... sigh....